Migration is never far from the top of the news agenda, but what practical steps are we taking to recognise, and address, the issue of people migrating for environmental and climate change-related reasons – now and in the future?
That was the burning question at a Friends of Europe policy insight event in Brussels on 8 November, which debated the complexities of defining, preparing and empowering those whose lives and livelihoods are impacted by environmental factors. These include events ranging from: sudden disasters like earthquakes; extreme weather events such as typhoons; increasingly occurring floods and droughts, and slower-onset challenges like rising sea levels.
With an estimated 200m environmental migrants expected by 2050, ‘Future Flows: forecasting and responding to environmental migration’ asked how they could be sufficiently protected and what plans were in place, or are needed.
The issue of defining such migrants – for example as ‘climate refugees’, with the legal status that comes with it – is still up for debate, explained Caroline Zickgraf, Deputy Head of the University of Liège’s Hugo Observatory.
The term ‘climate refugee’ doesn’t recognise that most people are internally displaced, “doesn’t encapsulate all the dynamics that link climate change and migration” and could lead to “misguided, isolated policies”, she said. As an example of an alternative approach she said some South Pacific island states had a policy of ‘migration with dignity’ and were pre-emptively training residents for integrating elsewhere in future.
Debate moderator Dharmendra Kanani, Director of Insights at Friends of Europe, said “the pace of change of climate change is re-writing what we need to think about” and suggested that the European Commission carry out work to provide an “evidential base” for a new typology.
Sheila Sealy Monteith, Ambassador of the Permanent Mission of Jamaica to the EU and UNESCO, said care should be taken not to conflate ‘environmental migration’ and ‘climate migration”, as it wasn’t straightforward for people to attribute their circumstances to climate change.
There was an crucial need for decision-makers to “more seriously understand” what was happening on the ground, she added.
Meanwhile Linnéa Engström, MEP and Rapporteur on women, gender equality and climate justice, said a global strategy for addressing climate displacement was needed, but it should be “gender responsive”.
Citing the fisheries sector, in which women’s work is essential but “never recognised”, she said women were strong change-makers and that “these are the people that we need to empower in order to tackle these challenges on a local level”.
In 2017, the number of forcibly displaced people globally rose to 68.5 million. By 2050, experts predict a significant rise in the number of environmental migrants worldwide – a number that comes in addition to the refugees, asylum-seekers and internally displaced people that will continue to flee their homes out of a fear of persecution. This early warning creates a unique opportunity for governments, the private sector and civil society to prepare for the changes to come and to seek out opportunities to curb destruction and loss of life.
This debate is part of Friends of Europe’s Migration Action programme, which aims to examine the imperative of migration in the context of economic sustainability and demographics, as well as its impact on public services, communities and security. This Policy Insight will allow speakers and participants to contemplate current and future climate change-induced migration trends, with the aim of offering concrete proposals on ways forward.
- “Syria shows it’s time to take climate migration seriously” by Esther Bijl
- “Climate change is a feminist issue” by Linnéa Engström
- “Water cooperation can bring peace to conflict zones” by Neena Gill and Sundeep Waslekar
- “An inclusive method to Europe’s migration flow” by Michael Printzos
IMAGE CREDIT: weerapat/Bigstock
Predictions about the future of climate change-induced migration vary widely, with experts citing the potential for 25 million to 1 billion environmental migrants by 2050, with 200 million the most widely agreed upon estimate. By looking to environmental drivers of migration as they stand now – such as crop failure, rising sea levels and drought – policymakers around the world may be able to work ahead of the curve to prevent loss of life, to ensure safe and regular migration flows and to prepare their societies for such possible disruptions. As environmental migrants additionally fall outside the legal definition of a ‘refugee’, and are therefore not afforded the same protections, is a new framework needed to fill this gap?
- Given that environmental migrants are not protected under international refugee law, what initiatives should be set into motion now to ensure that they receive sufficient protection in the future?
- With most environmental migration likely to take place within countries and regions, how are policymakers, the private sector and civil society around the world preparing for future migration flows?
- How can early warning systems designed for Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) be used to develop initiatives encouraging resilience in affected regions?
Member of the European Parliament and rapporteur on women, gender equality and climate justice
Sheila Sealy Monteith
Jamaican Ambassador to Belgium and Permanent Representative to the EU and UNESCO
Deputy Head of the Hugo Observatory – Environment, Migration, Politics at the University of Liège
Director of Europe and Geopolitics at Friends of Europe
As a proud advocate for mainstreaming feminism into the climate change debate, Linnea Engström is the author of the recent book Climate Feminism. In the European Parliament, she serves as Vice-Chair of the Fisheries Committee as well as a substitute member of both the Environment Committee and the Committee on Women’s Rights and Gender Equality. In her role, Engström has also served as rapporteur on the European Parliament’s report on women, gender equality and climate justice, which raises the issue of climate refugees and calls for mainstreaming gender into climate action.
Prior to joining Friends of Europe, Dharmendra Kanani was director of policy at the European Foundation Centre (EFC). He was the England director at the Big Lottery Fund, the largest independent funder in the UK and fourth largest in the world. Dharmendra has held senior positions in the public and voluntary sector and advisor to numerous ministerial policy initiatives across the UK.
Sheila Sealy Monteith is a career diplomat of over 30 years, currently supporting Jamaica’s relationship with Belgium and the EU. She also serves as Chairwoman of the African, Caribbean and Pacific Group of States (ACP) Committee of Ambassadors. Sealy Monteith has taken part in a number of debates, including on the importance of empowering women and girls to combat climate change. Prior to her post in Brussels, she served as Under-Secretary for Multilateral Affairs, Ambassador to Mexico and as High Commissioner to Canada.
Caroline Zickgraf’s primary research areas include the migratory impacts of climate change on coastal populations, transnationalism and transnational families and (im)mobility. Her latest research has led her to investigate the relationships between populations who do and do not migrate in the face of environmental changes, and includes case studies of Senegal, Vietnam and Japan. Zickgraf has consulted for the World Bank, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), the Nansen Initiative and the International Centre for Migration Policy Development (ICMPD) on the links between climate change and migration.
- Europe's World
- By Susumu Yuzurio
- Europe's World
- By Raphaël Danglade & Gareth Whalley
- Europe's World
- By Cordelia Friesendorf
- Europe's World
- By Cesare Onestini